Manitoba Human Rights Commission / La Commision Des Droits de la Personne du Manitoba

Home

Decisions

Manitoba Human Rights Adjudication Panel

The Human Rights Adjudication Panel has been using the Commission's website to provide information to the public about its processes and to host all decisions made under The Human Rights Code, including related judicial reviews and appeals.

Most of these decisions are also available on various legal databases.

The Human Rights Adjudication Panel (or Human Rights Board of Adjudication) is an independent administrative tribunal. Adjudicators are not employed by, or otherwise involved with the Commission and are appointed by the Lieutenant Governor-in-Council.

Any party may request that a judge of the Court of Queen's Bench review of a decision made by the Human Rights Adjudication Panel.

For more information see Guide to an Adjudication Hearing.

Decisions

2023

Wagstaff v. Green Drop Ltd, October 2023

Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Harassment, Employment, Disability, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Jaques v. Price Industries, October 2023

Harassment, Discrimination, Employment, Amendment of Complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2022

Madayag & Felix v. Capitol Steel Corporation – February 2022

Religious Belief, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2021

Madayag & Felix v. Capital Steel Corporation – June 2021

Religious Belief, Discrimination, Employment, Admissibility of counteroffer in 37.1 hearing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2020

Richardson v. Galbraith and Kirkwall Properties Ltd – January 2021

Harassment. Age, Sex, Source of income, and Marital or Family Status

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Webb v. LHS Holdings Inc. o/a Manigaming Resort., Sandra Carlson and Lennard Carlson – November 2020

Disability, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Sumner-Pruden v. Government of Manitoba – August 2020

Ancestry, Disability, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Richardson v. Wilma Gailbraith and Kirkwall Properties Ltd. - July 2020

Harassment. Age, Sex, Source of income, and Marital or Family Status, Amendment of complaint regarding the naming of the Respondent

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Zimmer v. Government of Manitoba - May 2020

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

A.B. v University of Manitoba - February 2020

Criminal Record, Discrimination, Employment, Services, Preliminary Motion to Dismiss

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2019

TM v. Government of Manitoba - Manitoba Justice - December 2019

Sexual Orientation, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

T.A. v. Government of Manitoba - Vital Statistics Agency - November 2019

Sex, Gender Identity, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Winnipeg Folk Festival v. Koshinsky - November 2019

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlment Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Pollock et al. v. Human rights Commission (Manitoba) et al., 2019 MBCA 110 - October 2019

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Court of Appeal -- Complete Decision

TM v. Government of Manitoba - Manitoba Justice - September 2019

Sexual Orientation, Harassment, Employment, Anonymization of Witness Names in Proceedings and Decision

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

T.M. v. Government of Manitoba - Manitoba Justice - August 2019

Sexual Orientation, Harassment, Employment, Anonymization of Complainant's name in Public Notice and decision

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Mousseau v. Southern Health / Sante Sud - 2 - August 2019

Political Belief, Discrimination, Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

A.B. v. University of Manitoba - August 2019

Criminal Record, Discrimination, Employment, Services, Anonymization of Complainant's name in decision

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

William Webb against LHS Holdings Inc. o/a Manigaming Resort – July 2019

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Services, Amendment of complaint regarding the naming of the Respondent

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Jane Doe v. Harry Rosen Inc. – July 2019

Sex, Physical or Mental Disability, Harassment, Discrimination, Employment, Anonymization of Complainant's name in proceedings

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Hampton, Sylvester v. Government of Manitoba and WRHA - June 2019

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Services, Amendment of complaint regarding the naming of the Respondent

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Nash v. Natividad and WRHA - May 2019

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

K.F. v. City of Winnipeg - Winnipeg Police Services - May 2019

Criminal Record, Discrimination, Services, Adjournment of hearing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Qumsieh v. Brandon School Division - May 2019

Ancestry, Religion or Creed, Nationality or National Origin, Harassment, Employment, Adjournment of hearing and Production of Documents

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Mousseau v. Southern Health / Sante Sud - March 2019

Ancestry, Religion or Creed, Political Belief, Discrimination, Employment, Adjudicator's Jurisdiction to hear complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

A.B. v. Jazco Management - March 2019

Source of Income, Discrimination, Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2018

Rankin v. Government of Manitoba - November 2018

Sex, Marital or Family Status, Discrimination, Employment, Adjudicator's Jurisdiction to hear complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Pollock and Kinvig et al. v. Human Rights Commission (MB) et al. - November 2018

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Court of Queen's Bench --

Leonhardt v. Government of Manitoba 2 - September 2018

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Nash v. Natividad - May 2018

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Services, Amendment of complaint to add Respondent

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Oswald Coombs and Benjamin Michaluk v. Magellan Aerospeace Ltd. and UNIFOR, Local 3005 and The Manitoba Human Rights Commission - March 2018

Age, Discrimination, Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

Ross v. 4888970 Manitoba Ltd. o/a Gillam Motor Inn and Michael Blahy - January 2018

Ancestry, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

North v. Government of Manitoba - January 2018

Sexual Orientation, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2017

Northern Regional Health Authority v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Horrocks - October 2017

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Court of Appeal -- Complete Decision

Leonhardt v. Government of Manitoba - April 2017

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2016

Kinvig v. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 30 - July 2016

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

Pollock v. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 30 - July 2016

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

Gordon v. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 30 - July 2016

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

Renard v. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No 30 - July 2016

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

Northern Regional Health Authority v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Horrocks - - May 2016

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

Szabo v. Cindy Dayman o/a Take Time Home Clean & Lifestyle Services - April 2016

Sex (Pregnancy), Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Jedrzejewska, Chaudry, and Chaudry v. A+ Financial Service Ltd. and Wayne McConnell - April 2016

Ancestry, Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

*Under Judicial Review

The Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Brockmeyer v. The Cornerstone Housing Corp. - February 2016

Social Disadvantage, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Housing

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

The University of Manitoba v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Damianakos - January 2016

Sex, Discrimination, Services

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

2015

Côté v. Manitoba Hydro - November 2015

Sex, Discrimination, Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Young v. Amsted Canada Inc. - November 2015

Sex, Discrimination, Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlment Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Collette v. St Adolphe Personal Care Home Inc. et al. - September 2015

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Horrocks v. Northern Regional Health Authority - September 2015

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

*Under Judicial Review

Blatz v. 4L Communications Inc. - May 2015

Sex (Pregnancy), Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Metaser v. Jewish Community Campus of Winnipeg Inc. - March 2015

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Damianakos v. The University of Manitoba - March 2015

Sex, Marital or Family Status, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

2014

Emslie v. Doholoco Holdings Ltd. o/a The UPS Store #425 - December 2014

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Walmsley v. Brousseau Bros. Ltd. o/a Super Lube and Super Lube Ltd - August 2014

Sex, Harassment, Employment, Motion to Remove Complaint's Name from Decision

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Walmsley v. Brousseau Bros. Ltd. o/a Super Lube and Super Lube Ltd. - June 2014

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Nachuk v. City of Brandon (Brandon Police Service) - April 2014

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Services, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Dick v. the Pepsi Bottling Group (Canada) Co. - April 2014

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment, Assessment of Jurisdiction to Hear Complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Brockmeyer v. The Cornerstone Housing Corporation o/a The Cornerstone Life Lease - February 2014

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Housing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

*Under Judicial Review

2013

Jewish Community Campus of Winnipeg Inc. v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Metaser - December 2013

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

Dunlop v. LMG Properties Ltd. o/a Bay Hill Inn and Suites - October 2013

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment, Pre- Hearing

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

Metaser v. Jewish Community Campus of Winnipeg Inc. - September 2013

Sex, Harassment, Reprisal, Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlment Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

*Under Judicial Review

Garland v. Scott Tackaberry o/a Grape & Grain - April 2013

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Kilbride v. A+ Financial Services Ltd. - February 2013

Sex, Harassment, Employment, Interim Decision on Production of Documents

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

K.K v. G.S c.o.b Hair Passion - January 2013

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

C.R v. Canadian Mental Health Association, Western Region Inc. - January 2013

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2012

Kilbride v. A+ Financial Services Ltd. - December 2012

Sex, Harassment, Employment, Interim Decision

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Mancusi c. 5811725 Manitoba Inc. o/a Grace Cafe City Hall - November 2012

Sex, Harassment, Employment, Assessment of Respondent's Settlement Offer

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Korsch v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Pritchard Engineering Company Ltd. - November 2012

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Court of Appeal -- Complete Decision

Blatz v. 4L Communications Inc. - June 2012

Sex (Pregnancy), Discrimination, Employment, Assessment of Jurisdiction to Hear Complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Chestnut v. Theo C. Ltd. o/a Hampton Inn & Suites - May 2012

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Kallen v. Midwest Pallet Works Ltd. - January 2012

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2011

Canadian Blood Services v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and X - December 2011

Sexual Orientation, Discrimination, Services, Assessment of Jurisdiction to Hear Complaint

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Pollock et al. v. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 30 - October 2011

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Services, Assessment of Jurisdiction to Hear Complaint

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Korsch v. Pritchard Engineering Company Ltd. - September 2011

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision

Wilcox v. Ladco Company Ltd. o/a Lakewood Agencies - March 2011

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination, Employment, Request to Remove the Respondent's Name

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2009

Hiebert v. Martin-Liberty Realty Ltd. o/a Amberwood Village - November 2009

Marital or Family Status, Discrimination, Housing

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Penner v. Fort Garry Services Inc. - November 2009

Criminal Record, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Ursel v. LMG Properties Ltd. o/a Bay Hill Inns and Suites - June 2009

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2008

The Manitoba High School Athletic Association Inc. v. Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Pasternak - January 2008

Sex, Discrimination, Services

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2007

L.H v. Vietnamese Non-Profit Housing Corporation - March 2007

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2006

Richard v. Brandon Youth Hockey Association Inc. - October 2006

Ancestry, Reprisal, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Thorvaldson Care Homes Ltd. v. Budge - October 2006

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Court of Appeal -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Pasternak v. Manitoba High School Athletic Association Inc. - September 2006

Sex, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Pasternak v. Manitoba High School Athletic Association Inc. - June 2006

Sex, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2005

J.D v. C.N o/a M. and C.A.G of C - August 2005

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Thorvaldson Care Homes Ltd. Budge - February 2005

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Court of Queen's Bench -- Complete Decision -- Summary

A. v. Natural Progress Inc. c.o.b as Little Chief's Place et al. - January 2005

Physical or Mental Disability, Discrimination (Failure to Accommodate), Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2002

Dubeck v. C.F o/a VY-CON Construction - December 2002

Sex, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Budge v. Thorvaldson Care Homes Ltd - March 2002

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

2000

Morriseau v. Jason Wall and Vivian Wall o/a Paisley Park - December 2000

Sex, Marital or Family Status, Discrimination, Services

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

1999

Schroen v. Steinbach Bible College - July 1999

Religion or Creed, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Bourrier v. Phil-Can Services Ltd. and Alain Caron - January 1999

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

1998

Werestiuk v. Small Business Services inc., et al. - October 1998

Sex, Harassment, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision

1997

Vogel v. the Government of Manitoba et al. - November 1997

Sex, Marital or Family Status, Sexual Orientation, Discrimination, Employment

Adjudication -- Complete Decision -- Summary

Winnipeg Office

p: 204-945-3007 | f: 204-945-1292
700-175 Hargrave Street, Winnipeg, MB R3C 3R8

Brandon Office

p: 204-726-6261 | f: 204-726-6035
341-340 Ninth Street, Brandon, MB R7A 6C2

Toll Free: 1-888-884-8681
Email: hrc@gov.mb.ca